Transdisciplinarity and assertiveness: acting within planetary boundaries – Ocean, climate, justice, and economy put to the test of reality

Admin — 2025-11-09T07:36:28Z

Lecture scientifique et opérationnelle de la table ronde d'ouverture consacrée à la capacité d'« agir à l'intérieur des limites imposées par nos écosystèmes et la planète » en ouverture du Hackathon Sciences Participatives Step One dans le cadre de la 3ème Conférence de l'ONU pour l'Océan à Nice, en juin 2025.

Table-Ronde interactive d'ouverture officielle
« Transdisciplinarité et assertivité – Quelles solutions pour agir dans les limites imposées par nos écosystèmes et la planète ? »

Intervenants :
Mme Nathalie HILMI, Chargée de Recherche et Directrice de la section Economie Environnementale au Centre Scientifique de Monaco (CSM) et membre du Haut conseil pour le climat de la Métropole Nice-Côte d'Azur
et
M. Robin DEGRON, Docteur avec habilitation à diriger des recherches en Géographie, Droit et Finances, Directeur de Plan Bleu UNEP Méditerranée,

Président de séance et animateur :
M. Thomas EGLI, Fondateur de l'ONG Objectif Sciences International, animateur principal du Hackathon
|en]
Scientific and operational analysis of the opening roundtable dedicated to the ability to “act within the boundaries imposed by our ecosystems and the planet,” launching the Participatory Science Hackathon Step One as part of the 3rd UN Ocean Conference in Nice, June 2025.

Interactive official opening roundtable
“Transdisciplinarity and assertiveness – What solutions to act within the boundaries imposed by our ecosystems and the planet ?”

Speakers :
Ms. Nathalie HILMI, Researcher and Manager of the Departement Environmental Economics at the Scientific Center of Monaco (CSM) and member of the High Council for Climate of the Nice-Côte d'Azur Metropolis
and
Mr. Robin DEGRON, Doctor with habilitation to supervise research in Geography, Law, and Finance, Director of Plan Bleu UNEP Mediterranean,

Chair and moderator :
Mr. Thomas EGLI, Founder of the NGO Objectif Sciences International, lead facilitator of the Hackathon

To read all the content, log in for free to the website.

Planetary boundaries / equatorial belt & vulnerabilities / marine heatwaves / sea level rise / ocean acidification / mitigation vs adaptation / climate justice / North–South equity / climate migration / blue carbon (mangroves, salt marshes, Posidonia seagrass meadows) / ecological restoration (grafting/genotype banks) / dynamic conservation (ecotypes/assisted migration) / MCDR (Marine Carbon Dioxide Removal) / ocean alkalinity (uncertain impacts) / GMOs/NBTs (varietal selection under water/temperature stress) / coral resilience (mutation/selection) / emission sources: transport (urban vs rural), buildings (thermal renovation), agriculture (N₂O, CH₄), industry (steel, cement), energy (France/EU specificities) / ecosystem services / carbon markets & biodiversity credits / debt-for-nature swaps / double materiality / participatory science / co-production of public policies / regenerative economy / transdisciplinarity & multi-disciplinary training.

Based on the contributions of Nathalie HILMI (environmental economics, Scientific Center of Monaco), Robin DEGRON (Plan Bleu – UNEP Mediterranean) and the moderation of Thomas EGLI (Objectif Sciences International), this article links physical diagnostics (marine heatwaves, sea level rise, acidification), socio-economic challenges (transport, buildings, agriculture, industry, energy), and pathways for action combining nature-based solutions, cautious technological innovations, financial levers, and participatory science. The central focus is on “operational” transdisciplinarity and assertiveness in arbitration between mitigation and adaptation, with strong requirements for climate justice, North–South equity, and ecological integrity.

The content below aims to serve as a methodological resource for readers.

"Transdisciplinarity is not a slogan: it is a method to clarify trade-offs between mitigation and adaptation as close as possible to coastal and urban areas." – Nathalie HILMI

"In the Mediterranean basin, pressure is accelerating: marine heatwaves, sea level rise, ocean acidification, and biodiversity stress demand co-constructed and governed responses." – Robin DEGRO

"Participatory science shifts the scale of what's possible: it connects citizens, researchers, businesses, and public authorities to co-produce public policies and evidence of impact." – Thomas EGLI

1. Context, corpus, and objectives

The discussion takes place during the official opening of the #ParticipatoryScience Hackathon for the #Ocean, in an interactive and multilingual format, and draws on the recordings and transcriptions as its primary source material. The scientific objective of this article is twofold: i) to synthesize robust findings on ecosystem states and emission sources; ii) to formulate a methodical, measurable, and replicable roadmap linking biophysical evidence, economic feasibility, governance, and citizen engagement.

2. Theoretical framework and disciplinary scope

The stated approach is strictly transdisciplinary: it goes beyond disciplinary juxtaposition to integrate “value interfaces” across natural sciences, engineering, economics, law, public policy, and social sciences.

The scope encompasses oceanography, climatology and climate science; marine ecology and conservation biology; forestry and terrestrial ecology; urban planning and urban resilience (green islands); transport planning (tramways, urban/rural contrasts) and building thermal performance (thermal renovation); coastal engineering and ecological restoration (coral reefs, Posidonia); genetics and biotechnologies (NBTs, GMOs); materials engineering (alternatives to concrete) and industrial processes (steel, cement); energy (transport electrification, nuclear specificities in France/EU); agronomy, agroecology, permaculture, and food security; environmental economics, ecosystem service valuation, carbon markets and biodiversity credits, debt-for-nature swaps, finance/risk management (double materiality, European directive); climate/adaptation policy and international law; climate justice and North–South equity; sociology, anthropology (endangered cultures, migration), journalism/communication and participatory science as a bridge between stakeholders.

3. Warning signs and consolidated diagnostics

In the Mediterranean basin and beyond, the physical trajectory confirms that we have already crossed several planetary boundaries: intense and repeated marine heatwaves, sea level rise, and ocean acidification with impacts on coral reefs and Posidonia oceanica seagrass meadows (blue carbon). On land, forest mortality is increasing, raising the issue of species selection under future climate. In the equatorial belt & vulnerabilities, cumulative vulnerability combines climate, biodiversity, food security, and climate migration.

The main emission sources (France/EU case) stem from transport (significant urban/rural contrasts and purchasing power constraints), buildings (priority on renovation), and agriculture (N₂O from nitrogen inputs, CH₄ from livestock), with a more nuanced role for industry (steel, cement) and energy (energy mix and the role of nuclear). These dynamics must be interpreted through socio-spatial trajectories (urban tramways vs car dependence in low-density areas) and recent political lessons on acceptability (e.g., "carbon tax" shock).

4. From evidence to solutions: nature, technology, trade-offs

Nature-based solutions (NBS) emerge as a “baseline”: protecting/restoring blue carbon stocks (mangroves, salt marshes, Posidonia seagrass), ecological restoration of coral reefs, and dynamic conservation (use of ecotypes, assisted migration, grafting, genotype banks) along coastal regions. Governance must clarify scale and funding limits and integrate positive externalities (coastal protection, biodiversity, health, education).

On the technological side, MCDR (Marine Carbon Dioxide Removal) components and ocean alkalinity are under study but require robust ecological assessments and methodological caution due to uncertain impacts. Engineering points toward a “green-grey” coastal engineering and materials engineering favoring alternatives to concrete and efficiency in industrial processes. GMO/NBT trajectories are also examined through the lens of risk/benefit/acceptability, both for agriculture and coral resilience.

5. Economic levers, finance, and risk management

Translating ecological benefits into decision-making language requires ecosystem service valuation and well-governed financing mechanisms: carbon markets and biodiversity credits, debt-for-nature swaps, insurance instruments, and finance/risk management frameworks aligned with double materiality (as per the EU directive). These levers should support a regenerative economy where flows restore more than they degrade, not merely displace externalities.

6. Justice, equity, and climate geopolitics

Demanding North–South equity and climate justice means acknowledging differentiated responsibilities, financing adaptation where vulnerability is greatest, and avoiding neo-colonialism in technical, normative, or financial architectures. Addressing climate migration must inform planning, diplomacy, and cooperation — beyond just humanitarian responses.

7. Social mobilization, participatory science, and scaling

Participatory science is presented as a “scale accelerator” able to connect citizens, scientists, companies, and authorities, to co-produce public policies and evidence of impact, and to “pierce through” decision-makers' awareness via direct involvement. Education and journalism/communication are needed for accountability, while companies and local authorities are urged to act as co-actors rather than mere funders.

8. Operational transdisciplinarity and project governance

Making transdisciplinarity operational requires multi-disciplinary teams, role clarity, a defined acceptable complexity threshold, decision traceability, and shared impact metrics. Recommended tools include a mitigation vs adaptation trade-off canvas, ecosystem service valuation matrices, and double materiality guides for projects and portfolios.

9. Case studies and application scenarios

Posidonia, ecotypes, and dynamic conservation — Restoring Mediterranean seagrass meadows benefits from using ecotypes more tolerant to high temperatures (East→West transfers), anticipating thermal regime shifts: this illustrates conservation as a dynamic process, not mere preservation.

Corals and biotechnological trajectories — Recent work shows extinction risks can be reduced via combined strategies of selection, directed mutation, and in situ ecological engineering — provided that risk assessment and acceptability protocols are applied cautiously. This mirrors broader debates on GMOs/NBTs in agriculture.

Hot city, livable city — In Mediterranean cities, urban resilience planning (green islands, shade, water) and thermal renovation reduce exposure to extremes and energy use; conversely, low-density areas remain car-dependent, raising questions of spatial equity and carbon instrument acceptability.

Materials and processes — Reducing the footprint of the steel and cement sectors requires not only process innovation but also alternatives to concrete when safety and cost allow, along with finance/insurance mechanisms aligned with technological risks.

10. Discussion: assertiveness, timeframes, and funding allocation

Assertive climate policy requires clarity on timeframes: radiative stabilization occurs over decades, while adaptation — a “front-line” issue in the Mediterranean — offers immediate damage reduction leverage. Financial flow reallocation remains a bottleneck: today, most climate funding is focused on mitigation, even as vulnerable regions primarily need adaptation; rebalancing via ecosystem services, biodiversity credits, and debt-for-nature swaps, backed by double materiality, aligns with a regenerative economy.

11. Roadmap for the Hackathon and beyond: principles, milestones, deliverables

Four key action principles are proposed: i) “evidence→policy” (protocols and indicators aligned with ecosystem services); ii) “local→systemic” (from site to coastline, neighborhood to watershed); iii) “co-governance” (industries and policymakers as co-actors); iv) “integrity” (caution on MCDR/alkalinity; safeguards against misguided financialization of nature).

Immediate milestones include: NBS teams (Posidonia, corals), finance/partnership track (carbon, biodiversity, debt-for-nature swaps), engineering track (coastal, materials), territory track (urban resilience, mitigation/adaptation trade-offs by geography), and agro-bio track (NBTs/GMOs vs agroecology/permaculture).

Deliverables: end-to-end project sheets, ecosystem service valuation models, pre-financing agreements, participatory science protocol, and media plan.

Conclusion

“Acting within planetary boundaries” is no longer a distant goal but a methodological imperative: linking the power of climate and ocean science to understandable economic instruments, cautious engineering, and shared governance that tackles both mitigation and adaptation simultaneously. Transdisciplinarity becomes a design and arbitration practice; assertiveness becomes an ethical demand — to state where we're going, with whom, and how we measure what is truly restored. Participatory science, by broadening stakeholder involvement and data foundations, offers a chance to bridge the remaining scale gap between ambition and reality.

To read all the content,
log in or create a user account for free.

Create a user account for free :

Registering with the site Personal identifiers

Enter your name and email address here. You will receive your personal identifier shortly by email.

Your name or alias (Required)

Please leave this field empty:

Your email address (Required)

Password(Required) Confirm the password(Required)

Personal information

Gender
Mr.

Ms.

Family Name (Required)

First name (Required)

Birthday

Biography

Address (Required)

Postcode (Required)

City (Required)

Country (Required)

Mobile: (Required)

Terms of use

I have read and agree the terms of use (Required)

I want to receive the Newsletter

Please leave this field empty:

Training for Development

Transdisciplinarity and assertiveness: acting within planetary boundaries – Ocean, climate, justice, and economy put to the test of reality

1. Context, corpus, and objectives

2. Theoretical framework and disciplinary scope

3. Warning signs and consolidated diagnostics

4. From evidence to solutions: nature, technology, trade-offs

5. Economic levers, finance, and risk management

6. Justice, equity, and climate geopolitics

7. Social mobilization, participatory science, and scaling

8. Operational transdisciplinarity and project governance

9. Case studies and application scenarios

10. Discussion: assertiveness, timeframes, and funding allocation

11. Roadmap for the Hackathon and beyond: principles, milestones, deliverables

Conclusion

To read all the content,
log in or create a user account for free.

Create a user account for free :

Personal information

Terms of use

Step and Go launches its international initiative to scale up impact-driven projects

Training for Development

Transdisciplinarity and assertiveness: acting within planetary boundaries – Ocean, climate, justice, and economy put to the test of reality

1. Context, corpus, and objectives

2. Theoretical framework and disciplinary scope

3. Warning signs and consolidated diagnostics

4. From evidence to solutions: nature, technology, trade-offs

5. Economic levers, finance, and risk management

6. Justice, equity, and climate geopolitics

7. Social mobilization, participatory science, and scaling

8. Operational transdisciplinarity and project governance

9. Case studies and application scenarios

10. Discussion: assertiveness, timeframes, and funding allocation

11. Roadmap for the Hackathon and beyond: principles, milestones, deliverables

Conclusion

To read all the content, log in or create a user account for free.

Create a user account for free :

Personal information

Terms of use

Step and Go launches its international initiative to scale up impact-driven projects

To read all the content,
log in or create a user account for free.